Modular Monolith Architecture Explained: The Disciplined Building
By manhnv, at: Nov. 27, 2023, 8:59 p.m.
Estimated Reading Time: __READING_TIME__ minutes
If Monolithic architecture is a single, disorganized building and Microservices is a distributed city, then the Modular Monolith is a well-organized, multi-story office complex. It takes the simplicity of a monolith and applies strict discipline to its internal structure.
What Exactly is a Modular Monolith?
A Modular Monolith is an architectural pattern where the entire application is still deployed as a single unit, but the code is separated into independent, well-defined modules based on business domains.
-
Single Deployment Unit: Like a traditional monolith, it's deployed as a single process (often sharing the same database)
-
Strict Boundaries: Modules enforce clear separation. A "Billing" module cannot directly call the internal code or database tables of the "Inventory" module. Communication occurs only through defined public interfaces (internal APIs)
-
Domain Focus: Each module encapsulates its own user interface, business logic, and data access for a specific domain
The Good Side of the Discipline
The Modular Monolith provides a great balance for many companies:
-
Simplicity of Deployment: You still only have one thing to deploy and manage, avoiding the huge operational burden of microservices
-
Clear Ownership & Maintenance: Teams can own and work on a module without fear of breaking other parts of the application, dramatically improving internal agility
-
Refactoring Safety: The clear, enforced module boundaries make large-scale refactoring or technology upgrades within a module much safer
-
Easy Stepping Stone: Since the boundaries are already established, extracting a module into a fully independent microservice later is much easier (often using the Strangler Fig Pattern).
The Challenges of Controlled Growth
While it avoids the biggest microservice complexity, it still has limitations:
-
Mandatory Scaling: Since it’s a single unit, you still have to scale the entire monolith, even if only one module is under load
-
Internal Communication Still Local: Modules communicate via simple function calls (not network calls), meaning a crashing module can still potentially take down the whole application
-
Requires Discipline: Without automated tools (like architecture tests or package management utilities) to enforce the boundaries, a Modular Monolith can easily decay back into a traditional, tightly coupled monolith
-
Shared Resources: The shared database can still become a point of contention and bottleneck if not carefully managed.
When Does it Make Sense?
This architecture is ideal for new or mid-sized applications that anticipate growth but don't yet justify the high complexity and cost of a distributed system. It’s also an excellent choice for teams that value speed and simplicity in deployment but want to maintain a clean, organized, and evolvable codebase.